In addition to the use of wide angles, low angles, depth of
field, the narrative technique of flashbacks, Citizen Kane was a kind of
criticism about the use of the press by the powerful. What can be said about
Citizen Kane that has not been said so far? 77 years have passed since its
premiere on May 1, 1941 at the RKO Palace on Broadway in New York. Today the
film is still considered a masterpiece that divided the history of American
cinema.
The film, inspired by the life of press mogul William
Randolph Hearst, consolidated a very young Orson Welles as one of the most
important characters in the history of cinema. He was only 25 years old when he
starred, wrote, directed and produced this story that speaks of ambition,
corruption and power, but also of loneliness and betrayal, of hurt feelings
where lack of love is key to understand the behavior of Charles Foster Kane.
Welles, who directed and acted in the film at the age of 25,
captured the relationship between power and the media; the main character
Charles Foster Kane uses his newspaper, Inquirer, for propaganda purposes in
favor of campaigns of personal interest and as a tool to finish off his
enemies. The enormous influence that the press has on citizens was the main
reason that prompted Kane to buy the Inquirer newspaper, initially thinking
about giving voice to the people. The great importance of what is being published
is reflected on the protagonist's obsession by personally reviewing all the
articles.
Hearst and the Press.
Experts agree that Foster is a caricature of American
businessman William Randolph Hearst, who controlled the newspapers Examiner and
Morning Journal. In 1898 he published the declaration of war made by the United
States to Spain. On April 25, 1898 the battleship Maine of the US Navy
sank in the Bay of Havana due to a fortuitous explosion. Hearst sent the
cartoonist Frederick Remington to the site, who once there found that there was
nothing strange to give news and that the sinking could not be attributed to
the war with Spain so he sent a telegram: "Everything is calm. There will
be no war, I want to return, "Hearst replied:" You provide
illustrations that I will put the war. "
Citizen Kane has been leading for 50 years the top ten on the list of best films of all time from the prestigious magazine Sight &
Sound. Since 2012, it is Vertigo, by Alfred Hitchcock, which occupies the first
position in the ranking that the British publication makes every decade with
the help of 846 critics, programmers and distributors.
The renowned critic Roger Ebert said that Citizen Kane was,
officially, the best film in history. The passage of time has only stoked the
strength of their images, the power of their narrative language with the use of
flash-backs, a spectacular staging with scenarios where small details are
appreciated, the use of highly contrasted images and the insistence of depth of
field, as well as the wide angles and the long sequence shots, which supposed a
revolution in cinematographic aesthetics and that have had inspiring effects in
later works.
The use of the narrative technique of flashback, the
inclusion of the viewer in the plot, camera movements, positioning and angles,
as well as sound and editing make the film one of the best American feature
films in history of cinema, ratified by the American Film Institute.
"Apart from his impeccable script, which addresses
issues such as vital futility, nostalgia, the value of simplicity or ambition,
Citizen Kane brought a multitude of technical advances such as an elaborate
staging, the detailed use of wide angle and depth of field, the fluid capacity
to move the camera beyond the frame, the ingenious use of montage or its
innovative use of sound as a narrative mechanism ",
On The Set
Filming this feature was not an easy task. Hearst tried to
boycott it and in fact he succeeded. Its premiere was scheduled two and a half
months earlier but was postponed due to pressures exerted by the almighty press
tycoon, who would attack the film in its media and try to prevent the film from
being distributed.
Total creative freedom
Welles was an ambitious young man who was trained
in theater and radio. He had carte blanche to do what he wanted despite of not
having previous experience in the world of cinema. This was guaranteed by the
succulent contract with RKO studios, which would make him the best-paid filmmaker
with greater independence in the history of American cinema. Welles moved like
a fish in the water during the filming and brought his companions of the
Mercury Theater to the set, among them his great friend Joseph Cotten.
Three years earlier, in 1938, he had achieved unparalleled
success with his radio address of The War of the Worlds by H.G. Wells. It was a
narrative that caused panic among the listeners, who took believed the
extraterrestrial invasion. As a result of that, he achieved the genius label
and his first film recorded his mastery as a filmmaker.
Controversy
The controversy that generated the film was such that RKO
Pictures received monetary offers to destroy it before its public premiere.
After a negotiation with Hearst's lawyers, the film company pressured the
director to remove some fragments of the film. One of the deleted scenes
referred to the suspicious death of Thomas Ince, a movie mogul who died during
a Hearst birthday party. During its production, Citizen Kane was known with the
code of RKO 281. At first the film was going to be called “American”, but the
head of RKO George Schaefer suggested to change it to Citizen Kane. Orson
Welles thought about calling the film “John Q”.
The script
There is an open debate about the true authorship of the
script, which was awarded the only Oscar of the nine nominations in the 1942 Oscar
edition. The veteran screenwriter Herman J. Mankiewicz, a heavy drinker and
addicted to the game, had attended many of the parties organized by Hearst in
Hollywood. Once, the tycoon denied Mankiewicz entry to one of them, claiming he
had problems with alcohol. The veteran film critic Pauline Kael published in
1971 in The New Yorker an investigation that pointed to Herman as the author of
the script in an alcoholic rehabilitation center where he was locked up to
comply with the writing of the text. In the article Raising Kane the journalist
demystifies the role that Welles had in the script and ensures that, despite
appearing in the credits, he did not collaborate in a single line. This
position was not liked by many critics like Peter Bogdanovich, filmmaker and
great friend of Welles who refuted many of Kael's claims. Charles Lederer,
screenwriter and one of the journalist's sources, insisted that the Screen
Writers Guild was never called upon to arbitrate the issue of credits. In any
case, Welles' tendency to egocentricity often moved him to disdain the
contributions of his collaborators.
Welles kept the set closed, limited access to footage, and
controlled Citizen Kane's publicity to make sure the plot was kept a secret.
The first months of filming Welles kept the curious and the press away claiming
that they were just rehearsing, which paid off. Filming took place between June
29 and October 23, 1940 on the Paramount set in Hollywood. It was also shot at
Balboa Park and the San Diego Zoo, as well as at Oheka Castle in Huntington,
New York.
The mystery of Rosebud
Rosebud is the great secret of the story, the last word that
Kane says before dying and has come to be considered one of the most important last
words in the history of cinema. Only at the end of the film does the viewer
know that Rosebud is the name of the sled Kane played as a child, the image of
a longed-for childhood. But Rosebud is much more; in fact it was the
affectionate nickname that Hearst gave to the private parts of his lover, the
actress Marion Davies, whom he tried to cast in vain to stardom. In the film,
Davies is presented as a frivolous and interested woman, but the truth is that
when Hearst went bankrupt, she helped him overcome the crisis by selling her
valuable jewelry.
About Rosebud Welles said that it was a resource to
"tear" the story. "The Rosebud trick is what I like least about
the movie. It's just that, a trick, and it looks like it's taken from a third
book about Freud for beginners, "he said. Steven Spielberg bought the
famous sleigh at an auction in 1982 for $ 50,000. When Orson Welles heard about
this, he said: "I thought we had burned it."
Narrative Error
Maybe few people will have noticed, but the truth is that
Citizen Kane has an important mistake at the beginning of the film. If Kane
dies alone in his room, how is it possible that the press is intrigued to know
the meaning of Rosebud, the last word that comes out of his mouth? Legend has
it that there were those who realized the error before the premiere of the film,
but Welles asked them not to tell anyone. It seems that critics did not realize
this "error", because the film had an overwhelming majority of
positive opinions after its release, although it was a commercial failure.
Reference.
Orson Welles claimed that, before performing Citizen Kane,
he had prepared himself by watching the film The Stagecoach (1939) by John Ford
about 40 times. He locked himself in his house and watched the legendary
western each time with a different technician in order to clarify doubts and be
clear about how he was going to present his story. So, when he showed up on the
set, he really knew what he wanted for his movie.
The original negatives of the film have been lost. They were
destroyed during a fire in the 70s. Also, the entire crew that was part of the
film has died. Kathryn Popper, the last actress who was still alive, passed
away in March 2016. Popper served as personal assistant to Orson Welles and was
the one who pronounced the famous phrase "What is Rosebud?"
Cast:
Orson Welles, Joseph
Cotten, Everett Sloane, George Coulouris, Dorothy Comingore, Ray Collins,
Agnes Moorehead, Paul
Stewart, Ruth Warrick, Erskine
Sanford, William Alland, Alan Ladd,
Arthur O'Connell
Awards
1941: Oscar Awards: Best Original Screenplay. 9 nominations
1941: National Board of Review: Best Film
1941: Circle of critics of New York: Better film